Christa C. Cottrell, P.C.
Overview
Christa Cottrell is a trial lawyer in the Chicago office of Kirkland & Ellis LLP who focuses on complex commercial litigation. Her clients include some of the nation’s largest companies, such as 3M, Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, Abbott Laboratories, CF Industries, Dow Chemical, Kering, Novartis, AbbVie and IBM.
Christa has successfully tried cases to a full verdict for clients such as Abbott, IBM, PwC and 3M. She has been repeatedly recognized by The American Lawyer for her ability to win difficult trials in commercial disputes, products liability and discrimination matters. By way of example, Christa led the team to victory in a trial for 3M in what is believed to be the largest MDL ever filed. In this case, the plaintiff sought $1 billion in damages but the jury found for 3M on all counts. The American Lawyer selected the win flagging that “the plaintiff showed significant hearing loss,” but the Kirkland trial team successfully made the case that 3M was not at fault. The prior year, Christa also led a trial team to victory in a high-profile retaliation and discrimination matter. After a two-week trial, the jury returned a unanimous verdict on all eight claims, leading to Christa being named the “Litigator of the Week.”
Likewise, Christa and her team won what is believed to the longest running case in Ohio history: the case was ultimately tried five times. The first case led to a large verdict against the client, considered one of the largest single plaintiff verdicts at the time. Christa and the team took over the case, won on appeal, and on every issue after a two-week jury retrial. The American Lawyer likened the case to “Groundhog Day” given the number of trials but found plaintiff’s persistence was “not working” any longer, as Kirkland “handily dispatched the case.” As far as commercial matters, Christa and the team took a $150 million claim against her client and, after a bench trial, won a counterclaim for $14 million for her client.
Christa acts as lead counsel in a number of high-stakes matters with billions of dollars at stake. Christa represented Sanderson Farms, the third largest chicken producer, in three different class actions, and over 100 individual actions, as well as government investigations. She has represented Blue Cross Blue Shield Association in what is believed to be the largest class action ever filed. And she has won or successfully resolved a number of high-stakes class action matters, including for General Motors, Baxter Pharmaceuticals, to name a few.
As far as other commercial litigation, Christa has won dispositive motions on behalf of IBM, AbbVie and the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association. She also has favorably resolved a significant number of disputes including, most recently, obtaining a settlement in excess of $100 million on behalf of a Fortune 500 company.
Within the legal community, Christa has presented on a number of topics concerning MDL trends and commercial litigation including Trends in Litigation, Northwestern Law School, E-Discovery Issues, Women in Antitrust, Trends in Antitrust Litigation and Government Investigations & Civil Litigation Institute. She is also involved with a number of Firm committees, including the Kirkland Institute for Trial Advocacy, Recruiting and Mentoring through Kirkland’s Leadership Council. As far as community service, Christa has served on the board of directors of the Center for Conflict Resolution for the past three years where she currently serves as Vice President. Christa has represented numerous pro bono clients, including successfully arguing a full reversal before the Seventh Circuit on behalf of a federal inmate and handling the subsequent trial.
Experience
Representative Matters
In re BlueCross and BlueShield Antitrust Litigation: Represent BlueCross and BlueShield Association and co-coordinating counsel for all defendants, in putative, consolidated class actions brought by all Blue insureds and all healthcare providers challenging the structure of the BlueCross BlueShield system under the antitrust laws. See Antitrust Lawsuits Target Blue Cross and Blue Shield, WALL STREET JOURNAL, May 27, 2015. Successfully obtained summary judgment for two defendants. See 2016 WL 6124143 (N.D. Alabama Oct. 20, 2016).
In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation: Represent Sanderson Farms, Inc. in consolidated putative antitrust class actions brought by direct and indirect poultry purchasers alleging a conspiracy to reduce output and raise the prices of broiler chickens.
Haff Poultry, Inc., et al. v. Tyson Foods, Inc., et al.: Represent Sanderson Farms, Inc. in a putative antitrust class action brought by a group of U.S. chicken farmers alleging a conspiracy to depress grower pay.
In re Plasma Derivative Protein Therapies Litigation: Represent Baxter in federal putative class actions alleging an agreement among plasma producers to restrict output and exchange information to facilitate restricted output for certain plasma therapies.
In re Canadian Export Litigation: Represented General Motors in putative class actions in antitrust actions alleging an agreement among vehicle manufacturers to inhibit the importation of nearly new Canadian vehicles. Court entered summary judgment for defendants in MDL.
Carlson Inc. v. IBM: Represent IBM in breach of contract/fraud action relating to outsourcing agreement pending in the District Court of Minnesota. After a three week bench trial, the Court found for IBM on all claims, including its counterclaim against Carlson.
Jelinek v. Abbott Laboratories: Took over representation for Abbott Laboratories in an employment discrimination lawsuit after the initial trial resulted in a large verdict for the plaintiff. The case was re-tried, in a three week jury trial, after which the jury found for Abbott on all counts.
Chicago Freight Car Leasing Co. v. PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP: Counsel for PwC in litigation involving claims of professional negligence and negligent misrepresentation. After a three-week trial, the jury returned a verdict for PwC on all counts, including on PwC's counterclaim against plaintiffs to recover its costs and expenses.
In re Hanford Nuclear Reservation Litigation: Represent Dupont in action alleging plaintiffs' thyroid conditions are related to radiation exposure. Case pending in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington.
Deguido v. Skidmore Owings & Merrill: Represented Skidmore in suit brought by contractor related to alleged negligence. Plaintiffs agreed to dismissal after discovery.
Infinity Tower v. Skidmore Owings & Merrill: Represented Skidmore in suit alleging construction negligence. Case settled favorably.
Applus v. PwC: Represented PwC in action alleging negligence. Successfully negotiated settlement for client.
Clerk & Government Experience
ClerkHonorable Cornelia G. KennedyUnited States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit2005–2006
Prior Experience
PILI Fellow, Legal Assistance Foundation
Pro Bono
Gilbert v. Cook: Represented pro bono prisoner in successful Seventh Circuit appeal for a new trial. Co-chaired subsequent trial in federal court brought against prison officials.
Dawn Sims v. Terry Jay: Represent pro bono client in suit alleging breach of contract pending in Cook County Circuit Court. Successfully obtained dismissal of counterclaim; case pending.
More
Recognition
Recognized in Lawdragon’s “500 Leading Litigators,” 2024–2025
Recognized in Chambers USA: America’s Leading Lawyers for Business for Antitrust, 2023–2024
Recognized in “Chicago’s Notable Women in Law” by Crain’s Chicago Business, 2024
Recognized as “Elite” by Illinois by Global Competition Review 100, 2022
Recognized as a “Litigator of the Week” by The Am Law Litigation Daily, 2021
Recognized as “Up and Coming” in Chambers USA: America’s Leading Lawyers for Business for Antitrust, 2021–2022
Recognized in The Legal 500 United States — Antitrust: Civil Litigation/Class Actions: Defense, 2018, 2020–2024 and Antitrust: Cartel, 2021 & 2023–2024
Recognized in Benchmark Litigation’s “40 & Under Hot List,” 2020
Memberships & Affiliations
Fellow, American Bar Foundation
American Bar Association
Illinois Bar Association
Credentials
Admissions & Qualifications
- 2005Illinois
Courts
- United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois
- United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
Education
- University of Michigan Law SchoolJ.D.2005
Order of the Coif
Associate Editor, Contributing Editor, University of Michigan Law Review
- University of MichiganB.A., English & Political Science2002University Honors